If you want to take your makeup to the next level, then an eyeshadow such as this is a good choice. This eyeshadow has no parabens, a preservative commonly used in makeup.
Amazon
Kaja Eyeshadow - Moon Crystal Sparkling Eye Pigment, Shimmering Brown Taupe Finish, Highly Pigmented, Glitter, 03 Tiger's Eye, 0.29 Oz