If you want to take your makeup to the next level, then an eyeliner such as this is a good choice. This eyeliner is produced according to vegan guidelines.
Amazon
3ina The Color Pen Eyeliner 137 - Ultra Fine Tip 14H Yellow Longwear Liquid Liner - Vibrant Colors, Matte, Smudgeproof, Flake Proof Eye Makeup - Cruelty Free, Paraben Free, Vegan Cosmetics - Yellow